normative

Get the Author's Own View of His Context First

The historical context of a text is important but must be derived from the author's own self-understanding rather than imposed by an anachronistic backward view from today; for example, Machiavelli told us his context was 'ozio ambizioso' (ambitious idleness), so calling him a Christian based on superficially friendly statements overlooks his own stated opposition to the Christian world.

normativepending

Speaker

Harvey Mansfield

Evidence Quote

“The main point is, get the author’s view of his context first. Then, if that’s limited or needs to be restated in terms of what we know today, go ahead.”

Source

Conversations with Tyler - Harvey Mansfield— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:31:57 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...