causal

Mismatch theory and affirmative action harm

Affirmative action can harm its intended beneficiaries via the mismatch effect (documented by Richard Sander): placing black students who would excel at second-tier schools into first-tier schools where teaching targets the middle of the class makes them more likely to drop out or abandon STEM majors, as shown by a study finding black MIT students were top-10% nationally but bottom-10% at MIT with ~25% not graduating.

causalpending

Speaker

Coleman Hughes

Evidence Quote

“while they were in the top 10 of math scores nationwide the average score was in the bottom 10 of math scores at mit... close to one fourth of the black students at mit didn't graduate”

Source

134 - Beyond The Politics Of Race— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:55:35 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...