normative

Victim Impact Statements Corrupt Justice

Victim impact statements bring the worst features of empathy and punitive desire into the criminal justice system, because an attractive, articulate victim will elicit greater punishment of the perpetrator than an ugly, sullen one, and how much an act offends our gut is not a good way to determine punishment.

normativepending

Speaker

Paul Bloom

Evidence Quote

“our punitive impulses would often feed off of empathy, are a terrible way to run a criminal justice system. For all sorts of reasons of bias depending on who the individual is but also because the question of how much something offends our gut is actually not a really good way to decide how to meet out punishment.”

Source

34 | Paul Bloom on Empathy, Rationality, Morality, and Cruelty— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:07:55 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...