causal

Up-Close Killing Differs Psychologically From Mechanical Killing

The difference driving the trolley intuition is that pushing a person to his death is an up-close, personal, affect-laden act of being the proximate cause of death, whereas flipping a switch inserts a mechanical intermediary, and it is psychologically and experientially different to live as someone who has killed by direct touch versus by remote mechanism.

causalpending

Speaker

Sam Harris

Evidence Quote

“when people imagine pushing a person to his death there there's this up close and personal uh very um affect driving image of actually touching the person and being the true proximate cause of his death whereas in the case of flipping the switch there's this mechanical intermediary and you're not you're not having to get close to the person who's going to die much less touch him and that seems to be an enormous difference”

Source

448 - The Philosophy Of Good And Evil— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:04:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...