normative

Plebiscitary petitions weaken deliberation and compromise

Making state-level referenda too easy is problematic—especially allowing constitutional amendments by a bare 50-plus-epsilon majority of whoever shows up in a small-turnout election—because plebiscites weaken the separation of powers, deliberation, investigation, and compromise by forcing a binary choice between a proposition and the status quo with no third option; directed petitions are institutionally more valuable than plebiscitary ones.

normativepending

Speaker

Daniel Carpenter

Evidence Quote

“It weakens compromise. It’s either we’re going to have this ballot proposition, or we’re going to have the status quo, and nobody gets to go into the ballot and say... ‘let’s think about a third option between the two that might be better than both.’”

Source

Daniel Carpenter— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:23:23 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...