factual

Replacing Planet 9 With a Black Hole Has Tiny Prior

The prior probability that the Kuiper Belt clustering attributed to a hypothetical Planet 9 is instead caused by a primordial black hole should be very small, because we know of many planets and planet-like objects but have never observed any primordial black hole — only large stellar-collapse black holes — so the planet explanation is far better supported.

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“you can always replace a planet that is too far away to see with a black hole that is too far away and too small to see, that is difficult to disprove an idea like that. But I think that the prior probability distribution you should assign to that is really, really small.”

Source

AMA | June 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:37:16 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...