causal

General relativity enabled the special-first-moment idea

Before general relativity, declaring a moment as 'first' was just a labeling choice a student could ignore by running dynamics backward into a symmetric two-directional big bang; only once relativity could enforce that there is a genuine point beyond which you cannot continue does the notion of a physically special first moment become coherent.

causalpending

Speaker

David Wallace

Evidence Quote

“Until you've got the general theory of relativity, any decision that a particular moment is the first moment is just a labeling choice. You can imagine saying, well, this is time equals zero, this is the first moment. It is forbidden to run the dynamics backwards from the first moment, but then your graduate student says, well, look, it's a free country, I'm going to run the dynamics back anyway.”

Source

158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:31 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...