normative

Stoplight beats deliberative justice—rules over discretion

Using Schmidtz's Desert Town parable, a manifestly 'unjust' stoplight (arbitrary but maximum two-minute wait) is unanimously preferable to a 'just' system where drivers argue merit at each intersection (minimum seven-minute wait), because the costs of achieving case-by-case justice are so high that even the least well off are better off with clear arbitrary rules.

normativepending

Speaker

Michael Munger

Evidence Quote

“justice is a fine thing, but the costs of achieving justice are very high.”

Source

Michael Munger on Antitrust— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:42 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...