normative

A Theory Contradicting Its Premises Is Bad

Carroll rejects consequentialism because morality is constructed from intuitions, and if a moral theory built on those intuitions reaches conclusions incompatible with them (as utilitarianism does in cases like Peter Singer's views on suffering), the right response is that the theory is bad and needs replacing, not that one must accept the counterintuitive conclusion for logical consistency.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“if the theory leads us to conclusions that are incompatible with the premises on which we built the theory, that just means the theory is bad and we need a better theory.”

Source

AMA | October 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:06 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...