factual

People Disprefer Explanations Making Untested Predictions

People prefer explanations that do not make untested predictions: in latent-scope studies, when two diseases explain the same symptoms but one predicts an abnormal value on an unperformed blood test and the other predicts a normal value, people prefer the theory that does not make the unverified prediction—even controlling statistically—which runs opposite to the scientific ideal of valuing testable predictions.

factualpending

Speaker

Tania Lombrozo

Evidence Quote

“this is a body of work focusing on what they call "latent scope"... if you have two diseases that could explain the set of symptoms. One of them predicts that if we did a blood test that we haven't yet done yet, you'd see an abnormal value, and the other one predicts that you'd actually see a normal value. People seem to prefer the theory that does not make the unverified prediction.”

Source

223 | Tania Lombrozo on What Explanations Are— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:23 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...