Fielding percentage is a poor measure of defensive ability because, as Bill James showed, to commit an error a player must first reach the ball; the easiest way to avoid errors is simply not to get to the ball, so stressing errors perversely rewards limited range—which is why the A's built a new accounting of the game to measure range directly.

causalpending

Speaker

Michael Lewis

Evidence Quote

“fielding percentage is just really what you're measuring is the number of error of the player commits given the number chances he has but but it has James put out to to commit an error you have to get to the ball in the first place”

Source

Michael Lewis on the Hidden Economics of Baseball and Football 1/29/2007— EconTalk
Created: 6/17/2026, 12:12:19 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...