causal

Beliefs First, Reasons After

In the overwhelming majority of cases we form beliefs through other cognitive mechanisms (perception, testimony) and only generate reasons afterward when those beliefs are contested; the reverse—belief formed by accepting a good reason—does happen, as when people immediately revise answers to deceptive math problems once shown the correct reasoning, but it is comparatively rare.

causalpending

Speaker

Hugo Mercier

Evidence Quote

“in the vast majority of cases, people come up with the belief and then they... when the need to arises, they justify it to others.”

Source

233 | Hugo Mercier on Reasoning and Skepticism— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:11:55 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...