definition

Underdetermination of theory by data

Given any inevitably finite amount of experimental data, there are always infinitely many theories that will fit it (the underdetermination of theory by data), so one must appeal to additional criteria such as simplicity or predictive power to select a theory; Barandes worried quantum theory might be a case where the theory itself is so intricate it overdetermines the interpretation, leaving no fully workable interpretation.

definitionpending

Speaker

Jacob Barandes

Evidence Quote

“there are always infinitely many theories that will fit it, this is called the underdetermination of theory by data.”

Source

323 | Jacob Barandes on Indivisible Stochastic Quantum Mechanics— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:16:52 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...