normative

OSINT raises unsettled combatant-status questions

The democratization of intelligence creates unresolved legal questions about who counts as a combatant: a civilian who photographs a Russian missile system and sends it directly to Ukrainian military intelligence becomes a combatant forfeiting Geneva protections, but a civilian who merely posts the same image to social media that the military then monitors and acts upon is not—yet their information enabled a strike.

normativepending

Speaker

David Gioe

Evidence Quote

“if i'm walking through my village in ukraine and i see a russian missile system being set up and i take a picture of that and i send it to uh ukrainian military intelligence well i'm clearly a combatant right i mean that's you know i then forfeit my geneva convention rights”

Source

18 David Gioe Audio Cia Officer On Outsmarting The Russians Chinese Spies Ukraine The Reality— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:59:51 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...