normative

Cross-Species Moral Ranking Is Philosophically Unjustified

There should be no hierarchy of moral concern across sentient species; each creature has evolved exactly the abilities it needs for its own evolutionary niche, value is internal to each form of life, and so ranking creatures (a whale over a cricket, a person over a dog) reflects only speciesist prejudice and ordinary corrupted beliefs, not any defensible philosophical ground.

normativepending

Speaker

Martha Nussbaum

Evidence Quote

“every creature has if it is still living in the world it has evolved to survive in its own evolutionary niche and it has the abilities and forms of behavior that it needs for its own form of life and there is no hierarchy here”

Source

309 - Vulnerability Politics And Moral Worth— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:59:24 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...