factual
Scientific Priors Are Domain-Specific Not Vanilla Bayesian
The criteria scientists actually use in theory choice—such as treating a constant being close to but not exactly zero as especially bad (fine-tuning), or implicitly coarse-graining over possible parameter values—are far more specific and fine-grained than plain neutral Bayesian probability and cannot be derived from generic priors; they require a cultivated education in physics.
factualpending
Speaker
Adam ElgaEvidence Quote
“there are real scientific standards in there. And it made me wonder, how are those two, how do I square those two things?”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:24:14 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...