causal

A Balanced Shaken Old Fashioned Needs Better Whiskey

To make a shaken Old Fashioned that is still balanced, you must boost taste ingredients (more sugar and bitters, since shaking suppresses taste) and upgrade to a better whiskey (since shaking amplifies aroma, including off-notes), so an entry-level whiskey that is fine stirred reveals its flaws when shaken.

causalpending

Speaker

Kevin Peterson

Evidence Quote

“because shaking inhibits some of that taste signal, you have to boost the amount of taste ingredients, meaning you have to add a little more sugar... But it also enhances the aromatic elements of the drink. And in an Old Fashioned, a lot of the aroma is coming from the whiskey. So really what I found there was I had to use better whiskey.”

Source

307 | Kevin Peterson on the Theory of Cocktails— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:44 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...