factual

Some non-tradeable sectors depend on immigrant labor

Certain sectors—lettuce, melon, cucumber, and apple picking, and most elder care—cannot currently be profitably mechanized or traded; elder care in particular consists of 'hard-core non-tradeable goods' (person-to-person interactions), so without low-skill immigrant labor these industries would not exist at least in the short or medium term.

factualpending

Speaker

Michael Clemens

Evidence Quote

“fully mechanizing it and getting products that are of the quality that can compete with imports is not now possible. And at least in the short or medium term, those industries would not exist.”

Source

Michael Clemens on Aid, Migration, and Poverty— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:10:08 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...