normative

Abortion Absolutism and the Haggling Argument

Anti-abortion absolutists could be moved off their absolute position by a thought experiment in which women become pregnant with 10-20 fetuses that technology could save: maintaining absolutism would require accepting a 10-20-fold increase in birth rates, which they would not do, and once off the absolutist position (per the Shaw 'we've established what you are, now we're haggling' anecdote) the rest is negotiating details like 15 versus 20 weeks.

normativepending

Speaker

John Allen Paulos

Evidence Quote

“once you get them off of this totally absolutist position, then the rest is haggling about the details”

Source

216 | John Allen Paulos on Numbers, Narratives, and Numeracy— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:15 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...