factual
ESP Paper Passed Peer Review Despite Disbelief
A Cornell ESP study claiming students could foretell the future was published in a top journal (Journal of Personality and Social Psychology) and treated as impeccable methodology, even though most people including likely the editor disbelieved it—revealing that perceived methodological rigor and peer review can shield deeply flawed, uncontrolled analyses.
factualpending
Speaker
Andrew GelmanEvidence Quote
“it had so many forking paths: there's so much p-hacking--almost every paragraph in the results section--they try one thing, it doesn't work. They try something else.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:45 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...