normative
Punishing The Morally Unlucky Is Perverse
Punishing someone who, through moral luck, caused a terrible harm they will never repeat—like a texting driver who kills a child and is already tormented—has no justification beyond deterrence as an object lesson for others; apart from that, punishing someone already suffering and known never to reoffend is perverse, and regret and punishment should come apart.
normativepending
Speaker
Sam HarrisEvidence Quote
“i'm not a fan of punishment in general and i think regret and punishment should come apart”
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:17:42 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...