forecast

P-Doom Estimate of 2 to 20 Percent

Silver's estimate of P-doom is a deliberately wide 2% to 20%, because definitions of 'doom' vary enormously—from literal extinction of all life (which he finds unlikely) to humans merely losing agency to AIs (which he finds dangerously plausible)—and the smartest experts he spent three years interviewing cannot agree, so as a Bayesian he defers somewhat rather than imposing his own gut skepticism.

forecastpending

Speaker

Nate Silver

Evidence Quote

“I say 2% to 20%, because the definitions are so different... the consensus in the community is like 5% to 10%. And I expand that outward because, I spent three years talking to the smartest experts in the world about this. They can't agree.”

Source

285 | Nate Silver on Prediction, Risk, and Rationality— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:37:07 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...