factual

Boltzmann brain cosmologies are self-undermining

Cosmological scenarios dominated by random fluctuations should be assigned very low credence not because we are 'ruled out' as Boltzmann brains by data, but because such scenarios imply that essentially all of one's beliefs about the external world—including the reasoning that led to the scenario itself—are randomly fluctuated and false, making the theory self-undermining; yet one should not assign exactly zero credence, since zero credence is impervious to all future evidence.

factualpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“you cannot simultaneously believe that the universe with random fluctuations is true, and that you have good reasons to believe that it is true. That's what it means to be self-undermining. So my solution to that is to just give very, very low credence to cosmological scenarios with all these random fluctuations in them.”

Source

AMA | November 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:38 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...