factual

Standard definition of life fails on edge cases

The standard astrobiology definition—life is a self-sustaining chemical system capable of Darwinian evolution—falls apart when examined word by word: evolution only happens to populations (so are individuals alive?), it's unclear if life is necessarily chemical, viruses aren't self-sustaining outside cells, and even self-reproduction fails for cases like honeybee colonies where individual members can't reproduce yet the colony is clearly alive.

factualpending

Speaker

Sarah Walker

Evidence Quote

“if you focus on each word in this definition they fall apart at some level and they're really simple things like evolution only happens to populations so are individuals alive or not is life chemical or not”

Source

388 - What Is Life— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:07:28 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...