normative

Utilitarianism breaks with infinite or huge populations

Naive utilitarianism is flawed because you can always win the moral calculus by adding more people: a quadrillion miserable lives can be made to 'outscore' a short flourishing civilization, which is unacceptable; moreover, the impossibility of defining a well-defined measure on infinitely large sets means counting all future people equally would imply the only moral act is preventing the heat death of the universe, which is absurd.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“Given the fact that we're just maximising something, utility or a number of happy moments or whatever it is, you can always find a large enough number of miserable people that you get more utility out of that than a small number of happy people. That's the fundamental problem with utilitarianism; you can always win just by adding more people to the game, and I think that's wrong.”

Source

AMA | November 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:38 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...