definition

Science Versus Expertise Distinction

Science establishes truth through methods that are shared, known, and independently repeatable by many people, whereas expertise establishes validity merely through the credentials of the person speaking; this matters because experts in every field tend to agree on a number of things that aren't true and pass those false beliefs from generation to generation, while science is the method of rooting them out.

definitionpending

Speaker

Bill James

Evidence Quote

“In science, something is known to be true by methods that are shared and known to lots of people; and other people can follow the same steps and determine that this is in fact true. Whereas, in something like handwriting analysis which is based not on science but on expertise, the only way that we know that this is true is that an expert tells us that this is true.”

Source

Bill James on Baseball, Facts, and the Rules of the Game— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...