normative

Anger is legitimate toward agents who could have done otherwise

How to feel about people who commit evil acts depends on the best description of them: if they were addicted, controlled, or mentally incapable, the appropriate response is to feel sorry for them, but if the best description (given what we know about them, not the microscopic state of the universe) is that they could have done otherwise rationally, then anger at them is perfectly legitimate.

normativepending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“If you have good reason to believe that there's a sense in which the person didn't have a choice... then the feeling I would feel for them is more feeling sorry for them. If you think that the best description we have of this person is as someone who could have done otherwise... then you can be angry at them.”

Source

AMA | May 2021— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...