factual
Fundamental mind-changes are rarer in economics than medicine
While economists do update on interesting studies at the margin, fundamental mind-changes about things close to one's heart happen less in economics than in fields like medicine—where a clinical trial showing PSA screening doesn't help led many doctors to abandon it—because the best economics can usually achieve is a natural experiment in which not everything is actually held constant, leaving room to dismiss results as unrepresentative.
factualpending
Speaker
Russ RobertsEvidence Quote
“And natural experiments--by 'natural' I mean that it's not a lab; not everything is actually held constant. Control isn't working as well as it would in an actually lab experiment.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:16 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...