normative

Why Killing A Person Differs From Killing A Cow

If cows lack a conception of past, future, plans, and projects and merely carry little information moment-to-moment, then killing a cow only ends a stream of good experiences—a loss remediable by other cows existing—whereas killing a person destroys an irreplaceable, self-authored collection of experiences, values, plans, and relationships, making it a different kind of loss; this licenses eating cows while still forbidding making them suffer, and is revisable if cows turn out to have human-like minds.

normativepending

Speaker

Jenann Ismael

Evidence Quote

“that sort of loss is no worse than not bringing another cow into existence”

Source

80 | Jenann Ismael on Connecting Physics to the World of Experience— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:20:24 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...