normative

Only consequentialism can value and contain honor

The only thing that could value honor appropriately—both morally and psychologically—and simultaneously contain its perversions is a consequentialist understanding of its effects: honor norms that extend male honor to women's sexual behavior are pathological because they create immense misery for no outweighing benefit, whereas honor that motivates hospitality and moral heroism (which self-esteem or dignity cannot quite motivate) earns its place by doing good for us.

normativepending

Speaker

Sam Harris

Evidence Quote

“you would want to argue that that kind of honor is pathological on the grounds that it creates immense human misery for no good reason... whereas in other cases where you're talking about things like hospitality and the kinds of moral heroism that can be motivated by things like honor and can't quite be motivated by its cousins like self-esteem or dignity”

Source

126 - In Defense Of Honor— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:10:38 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...