factual

Replication seen as hostile rather than complimentary

In the prevailing culture of science, replication is perceived as a hostile act—a threat questioning one's work—rather than as the ideal it should be, in which a finding important enough to warrant independent reconfirmation is treated as a compliment.

factualpending

Speaker

Brian Nosek

Evidence Quote

“Replication is a threat, not a complement in the pressing culture of science. Because, 'Why would you question my work?' is the immediate reaction. Rather than, what we would idealize as the response to replication”

Source

Brian Nosek on the Reproducibility Project— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:28 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...