factual

The Dualist Quadrilemma About Souls

A substance dualist who locates consciousness in souls faces four bizarre options about which entities have souls: only humans (implying dogs and cats are not conscious, as in Descartes), everything including protons (panpsychism), a sharp arbitrary line across the continuum of animals (e.g., one genus of toad has a soul and another does not), or graded/partial souls (a frog having an eighth of a soul, which is incoherent since souls seem discrete)—and every horn is strikingly bizarre.

factualpending

Speaker

Eric Schwitzgebel

Evidence Quote

“you got to take one of those horns. But they're all bizarre.”

Source

262 | Eric Schwitzgebel on the Weirdness of the World— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:22 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...