factual
The Dualist Quadrilemma About Souls
A substance dualist who locates consciousness in souls faces four bizarre options about which entities have souls: only humans (implying dogs and cats are not conscious, as in Descartes), everything including protons (panpsychism), a sharp arbitrary line across the continuum of animals (e.g., one genus of toad has a soul and another does not), or graded/partial souls (a frog having an eighth of a soul, which is incoherent since souls seem discrete)—and every horn is strikingly bizarre.
factualpending
Speaker
Eric SchwitzgebelEvidence Quote
“you got to take one of those horns. But they're all bizarre.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:22 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...