causal
Turning off early gravity cheats the entropy problem
Brian Greene's proposal that gravity was switched off in the early universe (letting matter equilibrate to a black-body high-entropy state before gravity turns on) does not robustly solve the low-entropy problem because it is not robust: it merely smuggles in a very special initial condition, which is exposed by reversing the problem (a collapsing version would not smooth out), and it has nothing to do with the Higgs mechanism since gravity depends on Newton's constant not particle mass.
causalpending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“The reason why I don't think that solves the problem is it's not robust, it's just equivalent to saying the early universe was in a very very, very special early state... if you took our universe today and you let it collapse rather than expand, even if gravity turned off in the early universe, it wouldn't smooth out while it's collapsing.”
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:36:54 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...