definition

Two senses of rationality: consistency vs substantive

There are two distinct senses of rationality in philosophy: purely formal consistency (analogous to logical consistency, e.g. believing P and P implies Q but not Q is irrational regardless of content) and substantive rationality (whether a belief matches the evidence). Decision theory studies the consistency sense.

definitionpending

Speaker

Lara Buchak

Evidence Quote

“one is just purely consistency. So you can think of it by analogy to logical consistency. If you believe P and you believe P implies Q, but you don't believe Q, you're irrational purely in the sense of being inconsistent”

Source

220 | Lara Buchak on Risk and Rationality— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:23:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...