The fundamental flaw in super-forecasting methodology is that it evaluates predictors on binary outcomes (did event X occur or not?) rather than on payoff functions, and binary options become less valuable under fat-tailed distributions because fatness in tails causes probabilities of extreme binary outcomes to shrink while the body of the distribution expands, meaning frequency-space accuracy is uncorrelated with payoff-space success.

causalpending

Speaker

Nassim Taleb

Evidence Quote

“out of-the money binary option would go up in value when you fatten the tail in fact they go down in value when you fting the tail”

Source

Nassim Taleb — Meditations on Extremistan— Joseph Noel Walker
Created: 8/11/2026, 7:35:40 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...