definition

Is an ecosystem a system or an apartment building

A fundamental unresolved question in ecology is whether an ecosystem is a genuine system with its own integrity and rules you violate at your peril (the environmental movement's premise) or merely an apartment building—a collection of organisms that happen to share a space and a few necessities; if nature is purely instrumental we have ample breathing room, but if there are real overarching cycles we have less room than we think.

definitionpending

Speaker

Charles C. Mann

Evidence Quote

“If it turns out that there really are these overarching cycles, which seems to be the intuition of the ecologists who study this, then we have less room than we think.”

Source

Charles C. Mann— Conversations with Tyler
Created: 6/12/2026, 4:52:01 PM

Your notes

Loading notes...