normative

Rule Utilitarianism Beats Case-By-Case Discretion

Societies should organize around a small number of fixed rules (Schelling points) rather than case-by-case discretion, because discretion requires every outcome to be adjudicated by a monarch-like authority, generates massive rent-seeking and backlogs, and the powerful are more likely to intervene for themselves than for the weak; even when discretion would help the weak, its transaction costs dwarf the gains.

normativepending

Speaker

Michael Munger

Evidence Quote

“If you want to use discretion, it means people don't know what the law is because the discretion of the state is going to be used to put a thumb on the scale”

Source

Michael Munger on Free Markets— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:17 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...