causal

Kafkaesque counterfactuals defeat minimal change

For some causal questions, the relevant interventionist counterfactual is incoherent or uninformative: asking how stressed Joey would be if he had two parents but were systematically teased for having one parent produces a Kafkaesque scenario that fails to illuminate the original causal question, showing minimal-change comparison can mislead.

causalpending

Speaker

Ned Hall

Evidence Quote

“whatever our answer to that question is, it simply does not seem to be illuminating the causal question we were asking in the first place.”

Source

76 | Ned Hall on Possible Worlds and the Laws of Nature— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:13 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...