factual

Backfire Effect Largely Fails to Replicate

The backfire effect—where correcting misinformation makes a false belief stronger, originally found by Nyhan and Reifler in 2010 with conservatives and Iraq WMD claims—has been difficult to replicate, with a large Wood and Porter study of about 10,000 subjects across 52 political issues finding no backfire and about 85% of subjects showing some corrective response.

factualpending

Speaker

Jonas Kaplan

Evidence Quote

“they were not able to find any evidence of backfire effect across any of these 52 different political issues in fact most of the people in the study something like 85 did show some significant corrective response”

Source

261 - Belief Identity— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:06:30 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...