normative

Ideal Versus Achievable Giving

We should distinguish what ideal beings purely motivated by utilitarianism would do (give away wealth down to the point of marginal-utility equality with the poorest) from what we can reasonably ask of evolved humans; demanding the saintly ideal may cause people to abandon ethics entirely and give nothing, so a more modest progressive giving scale will actually maximize total giving.

normativepending

Speaker

Peter Singer

Evidence Quote

“perhaps if you have a more modest scale of giving, still significant, but more modest, you're going to get a lot more”

Source

351 | Peter Singer on Maximizing Good for All Sentient Creatures— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...