causal

Same idea can succeed and fail; need parallel programs

The same idea — positing an unseen perturbing planet — succeeded spectacularly for Uranus (predicting Neptune, found by Le Verrier in 1846) but failed completely for Mercury (the planet Vulcan didn't exist; the real cause was general relativity); you cannot tell a priori which case you're in, so you must support diverse parallel research programs even though it's hard to do.

causalpending

Speaker

Michael Nielsen

Evidence Quote

“This kind of diversity, where you just have lots of people go off and pursue lots of potentially promising ideas, you just need to support that for a long time.”

Source

Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Michael Nielsen – How science actually progresses— Dwarkesh Patel Podcast
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:38:21 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...