causal

Reasoning evolved to justify, not to find truth

Following Mercier and Sperber, human reasoning evolved not as a way of figuring out the world but as a way of justifying our positions to each other in social contexts; this means we are good at seeing the holes in others' arguments but blind to our own, so well-constructed group settings with minimal willingness to self-correct can harness mutual criticism to converge on better solutions than individuals could reach alone.

causalpending

Speaker

Henry Farrell

Evidence Quote

“human reasoning evolves not as a way of figuring out the world, but as a way of justifying our positions to each other in a social context... we're really good at... seeing the holes in other people's bullshit, even if we are not good at seeing the holes in our own.”

Source

148 | Henry Farrell on Democracy as a Problem-Solving Mechanism— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...