normative
Three-Species Thought Experiment for Utilitarianism
If you were in charge of the universe choosing a species to create, Homo selfishus (caring only for self) yields a Hobbesian nightmare; Homo justlikeus (caring for self, close ties, and distant others only weakly) leaves enormous preventable misery unprevented because people won't sacrifice for strangers; Homo utilitus (people who keep their own lives and relationships but will sacrifice for others in great need, like a kidney donor or subway rescuer) would be a happier, more admirable world—showing that stepping back from our own values reveals expanded concern as more ideal even if we won't fully adopt it.
normativepending
Speaker
Joshua GreeneEvidence Quote
“the right way to think about it is in terms of just some of the people who are a bit more heroic than most of us--someone who's willing to donate a kidney to a stranger, or someone, like Wesley Autrey who is willing to dive in front of a subway car”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:56 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...