normative
Brain-in-a-vat dismissed on explanatory grounds
Carroll is open to the possibility of being a brain in a vat or living in a simulation, but if such a scenario makes exactly the same predictions as the ordinary laws-plus-initial-conditions theory, he will not pay attention to it unless some experiment or insight is better explained by the extra metaphysical baggage — applying explanatory parsimony rather than claiming the skeptical scenario is meaningless or impossible.
normativepending
Speaker
Sean CarrollEvidence Quote
“until we do some experiment or have some insight that is better explained by this extra little bit of metaphysical baggage I'm not gonna pay too much attention to it”
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:22:03 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...