causal

Temporary tax cuts and transfers shouldn't stimulate much

Economic theory predicts temporary tax cuts and transfer payments should have little effect on spending because rational agents smooth consumption over time, so the 2009 stimulus—overwhelmingly composed of temporary payroll tax cuts and transfers—was exactly the kind that even in theory wouldn't be expected to work, and its forecast of a return to low unemployment by 2011-2012 failed, which a Bayesian should read as evidence the standard view is wrong.

causalpending

Speaker

Jeffrey Sachs

Evidence Quote

“it was overwhelmingly temporary tax cuts and transfer payments. Exactly the kind that even in theory you wouldn't expect to have much of an effect.”

Source

Jeffrey Sachs on the Crisis, the Recovery, and the Future— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:26:30 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...