causal

Consciousness may be a broken concept like élan vital

We may be confused about consciousness in the way we once were about life: we treated élan vital as a deep life-force but abandoned the concept, and on a reductionist conception life became a less attractive moral focal point (cellular automata are 'alive in some senses'). Because we intuitively treat consciousness as a deep binary fact (lights on or off) and our intuitions are dualistic, if that turns out false it would be a bad foundation to have built our entire ethics around.

causalpending

Speaker

Joe Carlsmith

Evidence Quote

“We think whether something is conscious is a deep fact...Is someone home? Are the lights on?”

Source

Joe Carlsmith — Preventing an AI takeover— Dwarkesh Patel Podcast
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:37:01 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...