causal

Insiders and outsiders evaluate probability differently

People inside a religious tradition evaluate the probability of miraculous claims differently from those outside it; arguments like martyrdom proving sincerity or 500 witnesses ruling out hallucination seem plausible to those who already believe in the resurrection but appear crazy to outsiders, because evaluating what 'probably' happened depends on one's prior framework.

causalpending

Speaker

Bart Ehrman

Evidence Quote

“it's people who are inside a particular tradition evaluate probability differently from people who are outside that tradition”

Source

125 - What Is Christianity— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:10:27 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...