Chinese politics has historically oscillated according to the 'fang-shou' (open-close) cycle identified by UCLA professor Richard Baum, with alternating periods of approximately 7 years of 'fang' (openness) followed by 1-2 years of 'shou' (closure); as of the discussion, China is in year 13 of 'shou' and is overdue for a return to 'fang', and there are many people inside the party (not just civil society) who support liberalization

normativepending

Speaker

David Shambaugh

Evidence Quote

“the fun show cycle...fang is for open show is for close...seven years of pong and then there's a a kind of catharsis pull back for usually one to two years of show...this has been a repetitive process since the 1980s. So unfortunately right now we are in year 13 of show. China is overdue for a lot of fun”

Source

Breaking The Engagement: How China Won And Lost America | Hoover Institution— Hoover Institution
Created: 8/11/2026, 6:24:14 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...