factual

Counterfactuals Need Macrostates, Not Unique Microstates

Getting rid of miracles requires limiting counterfactuals to macroscopic states, because for any macroscopic state there are many compatible microstates—including bizarre ones where weird things (like turning into a frog) happen—but such outcomes are immensely unlikely, so the Mentaculus assigns high probability to the normal outcome (the match lighting); this raises the deep, under-addressed question of what exactly a macroscopic state is.

factualpending

Speaker

Barry Loewer

Evidence Quote

“I have done is gotten rid of miracles by just limiting counterfactuals to talking about macroscopic states, and that gives rise to a very deep important question... what exactly is a macroscopic state?”

Source

215 | Barry Loewer on Physics, Counterfactuals, and the Macroworld— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:02:57 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...