causal

Boltzmann Brain Belief Is Cognitively Unstable

We have theoretical grounds, not just practical reasons, to lower credence in cosmological theories predicting many Boltzmann brains, because there is no principled justification for believing one theory true while acting as if another is true; the Boltzmann-brain scenario is cognitively unstable since you can draw no conclusions and know nothing about the world under it, and since coherent alternatives that fit all the data and assume a low-entropy past exist, we should advocate those instead.

causalpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“I don't think there's a difference being saying, 'I think this is true, but I'm gonna act as if something else is true.' I can't imagine a principal justification for doing that... It's pretty clear that we can assume we're not Boltzmann brains, that there is actual regularity in the world, there is a low entropy past that we evolved from”

Source

AMA | November 2022— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:19:26 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...